Warner Board of Selectmen

Meeting Minutes

August 21, 2007

 

Meeting opened at 6:00 p.m.

In Attendance:   Selectman David E. Hartman – Chairman

Selectman Richard A. Cook

                        Selectman Wayne Eigabroadt

Absent:             None

Recorder of the minutes is Mary Whalen

Others present:

Laura Buono – Town Administrator,  Mary Hodgeman,  Brad Kelly,  Judith Rogers,

Martha Mical, Allan N. Brown, Richard Senor, Barbara Annis, Peter Newman, 

1. PUBLIC HEARING – ACCEPTANCE OF FEMA FUNDS

A Public Hearing was held to accept FEMA funds in the amount of $42,831.56 for flood work located at Connors Mill and Bartlett Loop.   

No Public Comments, Public Hearing closed.  

Selectman Eigabroadt made the motion to accept and expend FEMA funds in the amount of $42,831.56, Federal invoice #1643DRNH.  Selectman Cook seconded the motion.  All were in favor.  The motion passed.  

2. MARY HODGEMAN – REQUESTING NO BOND (TIMBER TAX)

Ms. Hodgeman explained that she logged her property in order to pay her taxes. Selectman Cook asked what the cost of the bond is.  Martha Mical explained on the initial intent-to-cut the bond was over $3,600, a new intent was received this evening and the bond will be $1,360.  Chairman Hartman asked Martha Mical to review the situation.  Martha explained that State Law dictates a bond to be posted if there are unpaid taxes, property or timber due.  Martha further explained that people are logging in order to pay for their property taxes; Ms. Hodgeman is requesting that the Selectmen waive the bond.  Martha is unsure if the Selectmen have the authority to do so.  The Selectmen reviewed the statute and concluded that Town Counsel advisement is needed regarding the authority to grant a waiver.  Laura recommended a conditional motion from the Board.  A gentleman in the audience offered to post the bond.  Laura will still seek advisement regarding the authority to waive a bond.  The two intents-to-cut were signed by the Board members.  

3. ROAD PROJECTS

Allan N. Brown updated the Board on road projects.  FEMA projects; there are 3 wetland permits pending (Gore Road 2006, Joppa, Horne/Newmarket intersection) fees were increased by the State along with adding a report to the Natural Heritage Bureau.  Allan also explained there is a grant that was suppose to be received by the Town for a pipe on Horne Street (FEMA approved), the grant has yet to go before the Governors Council.  The pipe costs up to $40,000 and takes about a month to order, Allan recommends moving forward and ordering the pipe (50% will be paid by FEMA when ordered, balance will be received when job is completed).   

Allan has received two quotes for the damage to Joppa covered bridge which is also funded by FEMA.   

Connors Mill Bridge is moving along.  Selectman Cook asked about a pipe on West Joppa that was due to be replaced with FEMA funding.  Allan said a grant has been awarded but when he reviewed the grant he found that it was written incorrectly (FEMA used the wrong job description).  Allan does not have the confidence that the Joppa project will be completed this year.  

From the 2007 flood Allan said there is $15,000 of repair work on Horne Street that needs to be done and a couple of culverts on Collins Road.  Iron Kettle, Newmarket , Collins, Bible Hill require paving; Allan said he won’t pave these roads until October.  Riverside Park needs some work along with some culverts that need to be flushed; all from FEMA funding.  

Allan is meeting with Weaver Bros. for the Newmarket/Horne project plus Allan will be meeting with the area residents on August 23 beginning at 7:00 p.m. located at the Town Hall.  Selectman Cook asked about the Natural Heritage reports, is the data base reviewed based on the location that is given.  Allan said he sends a topo map indicating the area to be worked.  Selectman Cook asked how long Allan anticipates the length of these projects.  Allan thinks it is going to take about a month.  Selectman Cook asked if the Town crew will be doing the work on Horne St .   Allan said the crew will do what can be done, Weaver Bros. will be assisting.  

Selectman Cook asked if work was completed on Red Chimney, Allan said yes.  Allan asked FEMA to come back and look at that area because during the flood the brook flooded the road in two places.  

Allan’s crew has recently finished the FEMA work from 2005 & 2006, and a large amount of 2007 work.  Allan just received notice that Mitigation money has been granted for Willaby Colby Road (ditching).  A list of completed work needs to be filed with FEMA.  Selectman Cook asked if all 2005 FEMA projects are complete, Allan said yes except the intersection at Horne/Newmarket Road that is about to get underway.   

Chairman Hartman confirmed that the Town is not in a position to lose any FEMA money.  Allan was asked if the question regarding Connors Mill Bridge was found out cost before reimbursement or after reimbursement.  Laura has not received a response from the State and has reminded the State that the question is still out there.  Chairman Hartman asked if there is a stockpile of gravel down at the pit that is sufficient to carry through the work on Horne Street with an amount left over.  Allan said Horne will use up the stockpile, in the fall another 1,000 yards will need to be crushed.   

Selectman Cook was approached by a concerned citizen regarding the ditch at the bottom of Red Chimney Road .  Allan explained that shoulder and ditch work from the top of Chadwick’s property to the end of the hill was completed because the shoulders were washed out (paid by FEMA); there is a culvert at the bottom of the gully that was found, cleaned out and is now operational.  

Allan said that the Precinct approached him about the water line on North Village Road and about completing a joint project (in 2008).  Allan would like to apply for bridge aid, because there is a multi-plate culvert that is rotted and needs replacement above Waldron Hill on North Village Road .  Selectman Cook recommends scheduling a Road Committee meeting to review the top ten roads listed for repair.  Selectman Eigabroadt is curious as to how many other projects need to be done in unison with the Precinct.  The culvert is believed to be #5 on the road list.   

Culvert work was completed on Duck Pond Road , not FEMA related.  Selectman Eigabroadt asked if any other projects (not FEMA related) were completed.  Allan said he has worked primarily on FEMA projects.  

Laura added that Ed Mical spoke with her about East Roby Road , paperwork needs to be completed on the Hazard Mitigation.  Ed wants to know if the Board would like him to proceed with that.  Chairman Hartman added that the Town has been turned down twice, the last correspondence offered help with the application.  Selectman Cook feels it is a good idea to resubmit the application. Allan said that last application was returned with notes from Hazard Mitigation; Allan said the application needs to be rewritten with the scope of work narrowed down to only where the river would cause a wash out.  A letter of intent is due on October 31st.  Chairman Hartman would like to review the current file.  

Chairman Hartman said that the State has completed work on Pumpkin Hill Road along Willow Brook.  

4. WAGES

Laura explained that before beginning the budget process she would like to know which direction the Board wishes to take this year.  Current wages have been requested from various Towns including those within the Wage Study.  Some of the responses referred the Town to the Wage and Salary Survey provided by Local Government Center .  The survey will be available in September/October; this year’s goal is to have the wages included early in the budget process.  The employees have been informed about this discussion. The LGC survey has 2007 wage figures; the Town is searching for 2008 figures, there is also the consumer price index for the Board to consider.  Laura suggested if the Board chooses a cost of living increase to apply the agreed percentage directly to the scale; this would help keep the wage scales to a 2008 level. 

Selectman Eigabroadt said the original discussion in the past started around the cost of living increase. In order to be fair and equitable to employees that do not receive a merit increase as well as those who do is to have an annual cola adjustment to keep the Town of Warner ’s wages competitive in like towns. The Budget Committee’s biggest complaint is having a cola and merit increase.  Selectman Eigabroadt continued by saying they are completely different, cola is to keep the wages competitive with like towns and the merit increases are for excelling in performance.  

Laura agreed by saying if a cola is applied to the wage scale for example if a person is on step 3 and the scale is adjusted for a cost of living, the step 3 level will still receive the cost of living but may not achieve the next step as a merit increase.  Laura is asking the Board for direction.   

Selectman Eigabroadt said if the Town of Warner is going to use other municipalities for scale adjustments, if other municipalities decide to give a low cola that may skew the average for the Town of Warner .  The goal is to keep the Town competitive.  

Selectman Cook agrees that the goal is to keep the wages competitive but he does not agree the goal is necessary to keep pace with the national cost of living.  Selectman Cook does not believe the Town of Warner can afford a Federal cola every year, he thinks the Town of Warner needs to keep competitive within the State of New Hampshire municipalities.  

The Selectmen’s office has requested current wages from 16 towns and to date have received 7 responses ( New London , Webster, Henniker, Hopkinton, Enfield , Bradford and Andover ).   

Selectman Eigabroadt recommends using the LGC survey, collected information from solicited towns as well as comparing positions with other towns. Laura asked the Board if they wish to add towns with comparable budgets.  After discussion it was agreed to stay within the core group of towns established by the Wage Study Committee except if there is a position that does not have enough comparables.    Chairman Hartman recommends reviewing the Wage Study Committee’s report to re-understand the philosophy.  Laura wants to make sure the comparisons are where the Board wants them.  Last year the work was completed and increases made, but at Town Meeting there was a change (wage petition from the Transfer Station) and would like to try and prevent another change at Town Meeting, such a change results in a divide between the employees.  A Department Head meeting is scheduled for September 4.  

Selectman Eigabroadt feels the budgeting for wages has a good start by using the LGC Wage Survey, collected information, and supplemental job descriptions to do comparisons. After meeting with the Department Heads on September 4 the Selectmen can continue discussion.  Selectman Cook asked Laura how she sees the process playing out.  Laura felt it went well this year, there is a process in place and would like to think the Department Heads can approach her with there recommendations and will encourage them to do so.  Laura thinks it would be a shame for another Department to go to Town Meeting, doing so throws all the prior work out the window.  Laura is hopeful for a cooperative effort with everyone involved, including the Budget Committee.  The goal is to complete the wages early in the budget process.  

This year Laura will sit with each Department Head and go over each employee in their department and talk about performance, longevity, education etc. and then come to an agreement on wage increases.  Selectman Eigabroadt asked about performance evaluations.  Laura will establish a September goal for the evals. Selectman Cook asked if an established amount of money has been set for the Department Heads to consider when figuring wage increases.  Laura said the dollar figure will come from the created budget,following with negotiations if necessary.   

Selectman Cook clarified that the wage scale adjustment will be completed and approved first.  Laura said yes, if the Board wants to keep the cost of living separate from the wage adjustment, if the Board wants everything rolled into one then no, the wage scale would be approved after.  The Board agreed to keep cost of living and merit separate.  Laura added that recently the Town has had difficulty hiring; the Town is not only competing with municipalities but also private entities.  Laura added that the Selectmen have been flexible allowing the Department Heads to look at the applicant’s qualifications and what they bring to the Town.   

5. PUBLIC COMMENTS REGARDING WAGES

Richard Senor said for his edification a merit increase and a cola increase are two different things, and he doesn’t think employees should expect merit increases, as far as the cola, Mr. Senor does not feel it should be Federal because property taxes are different all over the country same as gas, food etc.  Richard Senor feels the cost of living should be derived from the Town’s County.  Richard feels it a good “thing” that the Town is revisiting the wage scale.  

Martha Mical said one of the points brought up this evening is the Town is having difficulty hiring, and because the Town is having to hire more in the middle of the scales those wages are almost as high or higher than some employees who have been with the Town for a length of time, that is not fair.  The Board agreed with Martha’s comment and is making strides to move forward.  

Allan Brown brought up to the original Wage Study Committee throwing out any town that doesn’t have Highway Departments or Transfer Stations.  Three of the towns that the original committee used have contracts such as Andover , Salisbury and Webster.  Judith Rogers added that the towns picked for the wage study were picked solely because they were competitive, contiguous and the positions in the towns were not looked at first.  After the Board of Selectmen approved the towns chosen then the positions were looked at.  Not every town had every position; it didn’t count against the formula because the median was used.   

Richard Senor recommends not throwing out the towns that do not have Road Agents etc. keep them in for the positions you want to compare.  

6. MANIFEST

Selectman Cook made a motion to authorize the Treasurer to sign payroll checks numbered 39684 through 39730 dated 08/14/2007 totaling $39,661.78 along with accounts payable check numbered 39732 through 39766 dated 08/21/2007 totaling $18,449.74.  Selectman Eigabroadt seconded the motion.  All were in favor.  The motion passed.   

Selectman Cook made a motion to authorize the Treasurer to sign accounts payable check numbers 39680 through 39683 totaling $525.40.  Selectman Eigabroadt seconded the motion.  All were in favor.  The motion passed.  

7. STATE VETERINARIAN

Chairman Hartman asked Selectman Eigabroadt the status regarding the State Veterinarian.  Selectman Eigabroadt had no feedback at this time, but said he would within two days. 

8. PLANNING BOARD VACANCY

Selectman Eigabroadt supported the Planning Boards recommendation, moving Henry Duhamel from an alternate to a full position.  Mr. Duhamel has demonstrated strong participation.  Chairman Hartman has also learned of Mr. Duhamel’s active participation.  Selectman Eigabroadt added that Mr. Duhamel voices his opinion whether he agrees or not.  Selectman Cook said that he does not support Mr. Duhamel; no particular reason was stated but feels Dan Watts would make a good full member.  Selectman Eigabroadt made the motion to appoint Henry Duhamel as a full Planning Board member until 2009(Mark Lennon’s term).  Chairman Hartman seconded the motion.  Vote taken; Selectman Eigabroadt, Aye; Selectman Cook, Nay; Chairman Hartman, Aye.  Vote passed 2-1.   

Selectman Cook discussed if there are any volunteers for the vacant alternate position, there are none, the Town will solicit for volunteers.  

9. TRANSFER STATION FACILITY COMMITTEE AND ENERGY COMMITTEE

Selectman Eigabroadt asked if there is information available from the past energy audit, if so the created energy committee could use it.  

Beginning with the Transfer Station Committee; Chairman Hartman recommends the Selectmen being involved as well as members from the current staff and a member from the Recycling Committee.  Selectmen Eigabroadt recalls discussion having the Recycle Committee undertake the facility study.  There was a discussion but it was agreed by Selectman Cook and Chairman Hartman that input is needed from beyond the Recycling Committee.  Selectman Eigabroadt recommended the Recycling Committee along with experts from the community. Selectman Cook recommends a separate committee with a member from the Recycling Committee.  There are two members from the Budget Committee, Mark Violette and John Warner who have expressed an interest as well as all of the Selectmen. It is also recommended that a member from the Planning Board and a member from the Transfer Station staff be on the committee.  Chairman Hartman recommends the Director of Public Works as either a member or associated with the committee.   Selectman Cook recommends a person with commercial site construction expertise, possibly Rick Davies.   

Richard Senor commented being Chairman of the Recycling Committee and referring to a couple of members, why should another committee be set up when this could be added to the Recycle Committee.  Selectman Cooks response is that he does not feel it is appropriate for the Recycling Committee because other expertise is needed.  Mr. Senor feels the expertise could be added to the Recycle Committee.  Selectman Cooks opinion is a separate committee is needed.  Richard Senor feels that establishing another committee is a waste of manpower and feels all the Recycle Committee members should be involved.  Selectman Cook disagrees.  Martha Mical added that the meetings will be public, anyone can go.  

Peter Newman asked what the purpose of the committee is.  Selectman Cook said the committee is for the physical expansion.  Chairman Hartman added and its relationship to overall trash disposal for the Town.  Selectman Eigabroadt added that the committee will look out another twenty years and establish a long range plan.  

Pete Newman said so the Recycling Committee will be looking at single-stream to see how that works for the Town and the other committee will look at what is needed?  

Selectman Cook sees the Recycling Committees charge, which was given to the Committee when it was reformed, is to increase awareness and outreach about recycling in Warner.  Chairman Hartman informed the Board that the co-op is doing a regional study in regards to single stream recycling.  

Pete Newman said the information that he received is Northeast Resource Recovery Association is pushing for towns that do not have anything in place, if there is something working they don’t recommend a change.  Pete asked, shouldn’t the Recycling Committee be looking at that kind of recycling (single stream)?  

Chairman Hartman explained that Concord Regional Co-p not NRRAA has hired a consultant to put a picture together showing how the region would do by changing to single stream recycling.   Moving in the single stream direction is a separate question.  

Judy Rogers asked if the Town knows if a bigger location is needed, is someone looking into the State.  Laura explained that the State sent out their appraiser to the Transfer Station site.  Laura understands the State will present a cost to extend the lease and the value of the property for purchase.   It has been concluded that the State is not interested in removing the Town from the property but it was concluded that there will be a substantial amount of money to either lease or purchase the property.   

In conclusion Chairman Hartman said a committee needs to be formed and a list has been created.  Selectman Cook recommends asking individuals first.  Selectman Eigabroadt reiterated, he thinks Mr. Senor’s suggestion of having the Recycle Committee members joined by the other resources makes more sense.  Selectman Cook is still opposed, the meetings will be public and anyone can attend.   

Selectman Eigabroadt made a motion to establish a study committee for the purposes of looking into the next twenty years of Transfer Station adequacy to support the needs of the Town of Warner.  Chairman Hartman asked Selectman Eigabroadt if he was not advocating for the committee to be a part of the Recycle Committee.  Selectman Eigabroadt said it’s a committee that is needed whether it’s a part of the Recycle Committee or not is a separate discussion.  Chairman Hartman is viewing what Selectman Eigabroadt is saying along the lines of what Selectman Cook has been talking about, a long range Transfer Station facility planning committee.  Selectman Cook seconded the motion.  All in were in favor.  The motion passed.  

Selectman Cook recommended asking Ed Bender to sit on the Energy Committee, David Bates has volunteered plus Neil Nevins who has previously volunteered.  Selectman Cook recommended looking at the signed petition.  Selectman Eigabroadt recommended Ron Wirth.  Selectman Cook also volunteered.  

Laura will send letters to above recommendations asking for their participation.   

10. SIGN PERMIT

Selectman Eigabroadt made a motion to approve a temporary sign permit with provisos for Michael & Gatia McChesney and for Dianna Jamieson and Joe Mendola for Map 26 Lot 23 with provisos.  Selectman Cook seconded the motion.  All were in favor.  The motion passed.  Selectman Eigabroadt noted that the motion should be made first then discussion.  Chairman Hartman agreed.        

11. OTHER BUSINESS

Martha Mical inquired about the meeting agenda now closing 10:00 a.m. on Monday morning prior to the meeting and feels that could be a problem because the Board meets every other week.  Laura explained that emergency situations will be considered, the cut off time gives the Selectmen a chance to ask for additional information.  The Selectmen agreed.   

Selectman Cook asked what the next step is for Gugliotti/Fletcher.  Laura will send a letter explaining that the complaint has been found to be of civil nature.   

Selectman Cook asked about the salary status for Pete Savlen.  Laura explained the agreed hourly rate was decided to be $12.23. 

Selectman Cook received a phone call regarding logging activity on Melvin Mills.  Different uses for the property have been surfacing.  There is concern about a Public Service right-of-way.  Selectman Cook would like Laura to contact Local Government Center and ask is a Public Service right-of-way transferable for other purposes other than the transmission of electricity (could the right-of-way be given to the next property owner to be used as a driveway).   

Judith Rogers brought the Selectmen up to date in regards to the dog licensing process.  There were 251 outstanding dog licenses as of June 21, since then contacts have been made resulting in 20 forfeiture fines being mailed.  Judith also informed the Selectmen that the Town Clerk’s office has been on-line for 2 weeks with DMV and overall the transition went well.  

12. MEETING MINUTES

Selectman Eigabroadt made the motion to approve July 2, 2007 work session meeting minutes.  Chairman Hartman seconded the motion.  Selectman Cook abstained, he was absent during the meeting.  The motion passed.  

Selectman Cook made the motion to approve meeting minutes dated August 7, 2007.  Chairman Hartman seconded the motion.  Selectman Eigabroadt abstained, he was absent during the meeting.  The motion passed.  

13. BRIDGE AIDE NORTH VILLAGE ROAD

Selectman Cook made the motion to sign the State application requesting bridge-aide located on North Village Road #187/104.  Selectman Eigabroadt asked if the Town is sure money is appropriated for this. Selectman Cook said that the money was voted on at the last Town Meeting.   Selectman Eigabroadt seconded the motion.  All were in favor.  

14. NON PUBLIC SESSION

Selectman Cook made a motion to go into nonpublic session as allowed by RSA 91-A: 3 II (e) consideration of pending claims.  Selectman Eigabroadt seconded the motion.  Roll call vote was taken.  Selectman Cook, Aye; Selectman Eigabroadt, Aye; and Chairman Hartman, Aye.  The motion passed.  

Selectman Eigabroadt moved that the Board of Selectmen come out of Nonpublic Session.  Selectman Cook seconded the motion.  A roll call vote was taken.  Selectman Cook – Aye; Selectman Eigabroadt, Aye; and Chairman Hartman – Aye.  The motion passed unanimously.  

Selectman Eigabroadt moved to seal and restrict the minutes of the Nonpublic Session pursuant to the authority granted in RSA 91-A:3 III.  Selectman Cook seconded the motion.  A roll call vote was taken.  Selectman Cook – Aye; Selectman Eigabroadt, Aye; Chairman Hartman – Aye.  The motion passed unanimously.  

Motion to adjourn 10:01 p.m.  

Board of Selectmen    

David E. Hartman – Chairman  
Wayne Eigabroadt
Richard A. Cook